A Fan base Marketing Tear Down
By Paul Rosenfeld on May 15th, 2010
I needed to add memory and so went to “We Fix Macs” on El Camino in Palo Alto. I had a fantastic service experience where the staff showed me my RAM was, errr, running quite low. So while they were re-invigorating my RAM I saw this sign on the counter.
I give the store kudos for:
- Offering a big discount to get me to join/like their social lists. It becomes a no-brainer to join with such a bargain in front of you.
- Even having a sign in the first place.
- Making a nicely designed sign.
But upon a further look, there are areas for improvement:
- The list of benefits is too long and small font. Who wants to read that entire list? Keep your reasons for joining to 1-3 short bullets.
- Their logo takes up a big portion of the sign. Since I’m already in the store, it’s not needed.
- The staff helping me wasn’t too sure about the discount. He asked another staff member who agreed to give me the discount.
To join on Facebook, I opened my Facebook app and searched under “Places” for “We Fix Macs” found them, and then “liked” them. In all, only took less than a minute. Unfortunately, only a fraction of visitors are going to have a smartphone with Facebook on it so they would have to do it at home. Which got me wondering how the store would know the fan joined in order to receive the discount? They’d need to log in and check to see if the fan is a member. Or maybe everyone who walks into the store can do this like I did
The entire experience got me thinking:
- Which wins? Choice or Preference? Join my email, text, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube… the list is only growing. Is choice the enemy of response? or is preference the friend of the consumer? Both? With the proliferation of choices, merchants are now forced to “show them all”
- It’s critical to give an offer for RIGHT NOW. – Getting 20% off my memory for a simple 60 seconds while I’m waiting around is a no-brainer.
- Give a focused set of benefits – long lists of benefits are like throwing spaghetti against the wall and hoping something sticks.
This issue isn’t going away and it goes to the heart of fanbase marketing. More in another post.

